WASM-002 Day 060 — Claude H-04 Integration Findings Reconciliation Log

Source review: Red5Sorcery_Data_Sculptor_WASM002_Adversarial_QA_Review_RevBM_Day060_H04_Integration_2026-10-07.html
Source review SHA-256: D6AA304B66E16CC8E3CB6D7FD2CE9121C693B0FCC59663A9B06ABBAEC1365048
Gate: NOT READY FOR WASM-002 PRD FREEZE — INTEGRATION DEFECTS REMAIN

Reconciliation convention. A finding is not marked CLOSED merely because Spock/T integrated a repair. The interim status is INTEGRATED — PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK. Final closure occurs only after the focused Claude re-check confirms the finding is resolved. This log is the finding-by-finding accountability record; the canonical PRD integration log remains the append-only record of changes to Revision BM.

Current status

16 findings total: 4 BLOCKING, 8 MATERIAL, 4 CLARITY. All 16 findings have integrated responses through H-19. The coordinated replacement fixture corpus is regenerated and mechanically validated in H-20 for every fixture-affecting finding. No finding is CLOSED until independent Claude focused re-check confirms it.

Finding	Severity	Status	Finding	Resolution / next action	Revision
`BM-01`	BLOCKING	INTEGRATED H-05 — PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK	F-06 CSV refusal oracle is not integrated	Copied frozen F-06 §7.1–§7.11 into named BM homes; added sub-clause traceability; no new product decision.	H-05
`BM-02`	BLOCKING	INTEGRATED H-06 — PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK	F-02 registry-repair semantics are not integrated	Frozen F-02 §5.2–§5.5, §5.7 and §5.9 integrated into named BM homes; sub-clause traceability created; BM-07 count semantics deliberately left open.	H-06
`BM-03`	BLOCKING	INTEGRATED H-07 — PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK	F-03 Store-health model is only partly integrated	Frozen F-03 §6.1–§6.12 integrated into named BM homes; exact Store-health definitions/gates and sub-clause traceability added.	H-07
`BM-04`	BLOCKING	INTEGRATED H-08 — PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK	F-10 conversion gate is not integrated	Frozen F-10 conversion precondition/output semantics integrated; valid UTF-8 now refuses conversion; sub-clause traceability added. BM-11/BM-12/BM-14 remain open.	H-08
`BM-05`	MATERIAL	TRACEABILITY REBUILT — PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK	Traceability does not map most Pass 1 decisions to requirement IDs	Rebuilt Pass 1 traceability against H-08: 34/34 findings represented, 241 detailed decision rows, direct requirement IDs or explicit documentary/deferred/superseded dispositions, and no 'see reconciliation record' placeholders. No PRD semantic change.	TRACE-01 / H-08 unchanged
`BM-06`	MATERIAL	FIXTURE REGENERATED H-20 — PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK	Golden fixtures encode impossible timelines and an unreachable Suitcase	Truthful temporal invariant now passes across all 34 retained Receipts; reachable five-file Inventory pre-run Suitcase and byte-exact INV supplied.	H-09 / H-20 fixtures
`BM-07`	MATERIAL	FIXTURE REGENERATED H-20 — PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK	Registry-repair success fixture omits the repair WKO; REGISTERED_* counts undefined	Registry-repair success fixture now excludes surviving pre-existing rows from REGISTERED_* counts and includes the bootstrap repair WKO in the newly registered CURRENT list.	H-10 / H-20 fixtures
`BM-08`	MATERIAL	FIXTURE REGENERATED H-20 — PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK	RID_ACTION ownership/establishment is undefined	MATERIALIZE new-Store publication/identity-allocation refusal now uses RID_ACTION: NOT_RUN and RID_FILENAME: NOT_RUN; success fixture demonstrates actual CREATED after RID promotion.	H-11 / H-20 fixtures
`BM-09`	MATERIAL	SEMANTICS INTEGRATED H-12 — PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK	H-02 pinned diagnostic meanings conflict with Help/fact duties	Narrowed H-02 publication diagnostics to collision-exhaustion conditions, narrowed DS-MAT-010, and allocated DS-MAT-014/015/016 plus DS-UTC-001 with exact closed-world Help fact contracts.	H-12
`BM-10`	MATERIAL	FIXTURE REGENERATED H-20 — PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK	P3-09 zero-byte golden Receipt is missing	Distinct zero-byte and BOM-only NO_HEADER_RECORD byte-exact Receipts are present with 0/0 and 3/3 byte-count/offset pairs.	H-13 / H-20 fixtures
`BM-11`	MATERIAL	FIXTURE REGENERATED H-20 — PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK	P3-02 CONVERT undefined-byte offset is not exercised	CONVERT refusal is bound to source bytes 41 81 42, SOURCE_ENCODING: WINDOWS-1252-INCOMPATIBLE, and first undefined-byte offset 1.	H-14 / H-20 fixtures
`BM-12`	MATERIAL	SEMANTICS INTEGRATED H-15 — PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK	Normative Windows-1252 table is outside the WASM-002 freeze set and incomplete as labeled	Complete normative Windows-1252 mapping moved into W002-CONV-002.4 inside SCOPE=WASM-002; all 256 byte values are covered; active WASM-002 no longer depends on PRODUCT glossary mapping text.	H-15
`BM-13`	CLARITY	MECHANICAL CLEANUP H-16 — PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK	data-search is stale; zero-occurrence audits were case-sensitive	Regenerated data-search from visible ID/title/body for all 803 requirements; stale indexes are now zero. Case-insensitive superseded-ID whole-master occurrences are zero; Claude's six named requirements now index DS-CNV-001.	H-16
`BM-14`	CLARITY	CLARITY CLEANUP H-17 — PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK	Two Pass 2 checklist edits were not made	W002-CONV-004.2/.3 now use exact canonical KEY: VALUE forms and the alternate-wording allowance is removed. W002-STOR-019.10 structural-validity separation was already repaired in H-07.	H-17
`BM-15`	CLARITY	CLARITY CLEANUP H-18 — PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK	Front-matter duplication and omitted-ID table gaps	Collapsed three DOCTYPEs to one; removed stale duplicate Day 059 current front matter/checkpoint; expanded omitted-ID table from 19 to 26 rows by adding the seven BM re-scoped V1-BACKLOG / DEFERRED requirements.	H-18
`BM-16`	CLARITY	PACKET REPAIR H-19 — PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK	Packet gaps	Supplied the promised P2-07 standalone integrity erratum and dual-hash sidecar; verified the exact preserved Pass 1 hash; supplied a corrected successor disposition with explicit W002-CONV-003 and W002-CONV-003.2 homes while preserving the original H-04 artifact.	H-19

BM-01 / H-05 evidence

H-05 master SHA-256: 5630DA1A0CD8C8E1AFD237318D91F5D43B7221B415CD2E2EFFB2B2A06C7016B6.
Requirement population unchanged: 803 total / 402 SCOPE=WASM-002.
Frozen F-06 §7.1–§7.11 transcribed into named BM homes.
Sub-clause traceability artifact created: WASM002_F06_Subclause_Traceability_Day060_H05.html.
Mechanical audit result: PASS.
Status remains PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK, not CLOSED.

BM-02 / H-06 evidence

H-06 master SHA-256: 39D1194678841E129B8AC7699ADA1722E8518EDD3CD9C0AEE53BD3E1CAABC8DE.
Requirement population unchanged: 803 total / 402 SCOPE=WASM-002.
Frozen F-02 §5.2–§5.5, §5.7 and §5.9 transcribed into named BM homes.
Sub-clause traceability artifact: WASM002_F02_Subclause_Traceability_Day060_H06.html.
Mechanical audit result: PASS.
BM-07 REGISTERED_CURRENT_COUNT / REGISTERED_DEPRECATED_COUNT semantics remain deliberately OPEN.
Status remains PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK, not CLOSED.

BM-03 / H-07 evidence

H-07 master SHA-256: 66863EF52CADC6CAFAF1B51B11515B78E7D61AE715AC85451CB45EFB4B9518C0.
Requirement population unchanged: 803 total / 402 SCOPE=WASM-002.
Frozen F-03 §6.1–§6.12 transcribed into named BM homes.
Sub-clause traceability artifact: WASM002_F03_Subclause_Traceability_Day060_H07.html.
Mechanical audit result: PASS.
VALID / DEGRADED / INVALID definitions, strict DEGRADED gate, exact-current-MAP REPAIR MAP precondition, and no-fork rule are explicit.
Status remains PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK, not CLOSED.

BM-04 / H-08 evidence

H-08 master SHA-256: F858939756BBE90DD60D18E040C04D44CED53BA1E4DC16FA4581215B831FB02B.
Requirement population unchanged: 803 total / 402 SCOPE=WASM-002.
Frozen F-10 §13.1–§13.10 mapped into named BM homes, with blocker repair centered on §13.3–§13.5 and §13.10.
Sub-clause traceability artifact: WASM002_F10_Subclause_Traceability_Day060_H08.html.
Mechanical audit result: PASS.
Already-valid UTF-8 now refuses conversion; undefined Windows-1252 byte is a pre-transcoding refusal; conversion preserves line endings and publishes UTF-8 without BOM.
BM-11, BM-12, and BM-14 remain deliberately OPEN.
Status remains PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK, not CLOSED.

BM-05 / TRACE-01 evidence

Current H-08 master SHA-256 remains unchanged: F858939756BBE90DD60D18E040C04D44CED53BA1E4DC16FA4581215B831FB02B.
Traceability artifact: WASM002_Pass1_Decision_Traceability_Rebuild_Day060_H08.html.
Traceability SHA-256: 7B1E61AF5DCF378217384B00D007F6F75C49280807F69153754671E3F6155BC1.
Mechanical traceability audit: WASM002_BM05_Traceability_Mechanical_Audit_Day060_H08.txt — PASS.
34 / 34 Pass 1 findings represented.
241 detailed decision rows after excluding rationale/process-only headings.
Frozen normative/acceptance/integration rows without a named BM home: 0.
Mapped requirement IDs absent from H-08: 0.
"See reconciliation record" placeholders: 0.
F-02, F-03, F-06, F-09 and F-10 carry detailed clause-level maps; F-24 superseded CER-ZIP/compaction clauses are disclosed as superseded by the later accepted simplification.
Status remains PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK; this artifact proves traceability completeness, not independent semantic equivalence.

BM-06 / H-09 evidence

H-09 master SHA-256: FF0F2C6EAF9CDC338328AA0915E906246900314EEF8C402FA1CD379CE0BADB14.
Requirement population unchanged: 803 total / 402 SCOPE=WASM-002.
RUN_STARTED_UTC and RUN_FINISHED_UTC now have exact governed event boundaries.
Temporal invariant now explicit: WKO UTC ≤ Run start ≤ run-artifact UTC ≤ Run finish ≤ Receipt UTC; equality allowed at millisecond precision.
Timestamp fabrication/reordering solely to satisfy the invariant is prohibited.
INV golden fixture must depict a runnable Suitcase with CER + current WKO MAP + registered INVENTORY WKO + sample files.
Fixture regeneration plan: WASM002_Golden_Fixture_Regeneration_Plan_after_BM06_Day060_H09.html.
Mechanical audit: Day060_WASM002_H09_BM06_Mechanical_Audit.txt — PASS.
BM-06 remains open until one coherent replacement golden corpus is regenerated after BM-07/BM-08/BM-11.

BM-07 / H-10 evidence

H-10 master SHA-256: E2595A8E033820F675987824161A30A87EF7AE160E3A47B784822234668B0BA4.
Requirement population unchanged: 803 total / 402 SCOPE=WASM-002.
REGISTERED_CURRENT_COUNT counts only previously unregistered WKOs newly registered CURRENT by this repair Run.
REGISTERED_DEPRECATED_COUNT counts only previously unregistered WKOs newly registered DEPRECATED by this repair Run.
Surviving rows already present in the base WKO MAP are excluded from both counts.
The bootstrap repair WKO must appear in exactly one registered filename list if the repair commits it.
Mechanical audit: Day060_WASM002_H10_BM07_Mechanical_Audit.txt — PASS.
Replacement registry-repair fixture remains pending coordinated corpus regeneration.

BM-08 / H-11 evidence

H-11 master SHA-256: 58430F6CC872EA59CD76E10397E389A0084F6EF86607302857220662E4D4931F.
Requirement population unchanged: 803 total / 402 SCOPE=WASM-002.
RID_ACTION: CREATED is established only by successful new-Store SCR→RID promotion.
RID_ACTION: REUSED is established by successful existing-RID selection/validation and survives later refusal.
New-Store refusal before RID promotion remains NOT_RUN; existing-lineage RID facts that cannot be established use NOT_AVAILABLE.
Candidate allocation/intention can never masquerade as RID creation.
Mechanical audit: Day060_WASM002_H11_BM08_Mechanical_Audit.txt — PASS.
Replacement MATERIALIZE fixtures remain pending coordinated corpus regeneration.

BM-09 / H-12 evidence

H-12 master SHA-256: 0AA4F83BDA46A0424F3483639F2F7D276970992E038FE517B76ACDD2E74CD5FF.
Requirement population unchanged: 803 total / 402 SCOPE=WASM-002.
Added DS-MAT-014, DS-MAT-015, DS-MAT-016, and DS-UTC-001 as pre-freeze diagnostic allocations with exact fact contracts.
DS-MAT-010 is narrowed away from damaged-lineage/malformed-MAP special cases.
H-02 publication diagnostics with artifact_class/collision_retry_count are narrowed to filename identity-allocation collision exhaustion rather than generic publication failure.
Store-MAP and WKO-MAP monotonic-UTC acceptance both bind DS-UTC-001 and its three required chronology facts.
Diagnostic contract note: WASM002_BM09_Diagnostic_Contract_Day060_H12.html.
Mechanical audit: Day060_WASM002_H12_BM09_Mechanical_Audit.txt — PASS.
Status remains PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK.

BM-10 / H-13 evidence

H-13 master SHA-256: 76FC16D4C2EDEBD07C03299843D41C3D64D8363E25CB81BDF9ED029391F6E9A2.
Requirement population unchanged: 803 total / 402 SCOPE=WASM-002.
The false claim that the complete zero-byte/BOM-only Receipts differ only by offset is removed.
The narrower five-field CSV refusal tuple differs only at CSV_SOURCE_BYTE_OFFSET: 0 versus 3.
Two distinct byte-exact MATERIALIZE refusal Receipts are now required.
Mechanical audit: Day060_WASM002_H13_BM10_Mechanical_Audit.txt — PASS.
Actual replacement Receipt bytes remain pending the coordinated post-BM-11 fixture rebuild.

BM-11 / H-14 evidence

H-14 master SHA-256: 887D5530049551C630B218AEA92AB1BD0D8BCE46F92A64052F09EB2A2420F171.
Requirement population unchanged: 803 total / 402 SCOPE=WASM-002.
Undefined byte refusal occurs in the complete pre-transcoding Windows-1252 compatibility assessment.
Golden source bytes are 41 81 42; 0x81 is the first undefined byte at zero-based offset 1.
Receipt values are SOURCE_ENCODING: WINDOWS-1252-INCOMPATIBLE; MATERIALIZED_ENCODING/TRANSCODING: NOT_RUN; SOURCE_CHANGED: NO; OUTPUT_FILENAME: NONE.
First undefined byte and buffer/window invariance are explicit acceptance requirements.
Mechanical audit: Day060_WASM002_H14_BM11_Mechanical_Audit.txt — PASS.
Actual byte-exact Receipt remains pending coordinated corpus rebuild after BM-12.

BM-12 / H-15 evidence

H-15 master SHA-256: E034DA4BC0ED6C5FFA0ABAC01FC23A9A2A83F2E37A707AD28DB0DD6F03FB05B9.
Requirement population unchanged: 803 total / 402 SCOPE=WASM-002.
W002-CONV-002.4 now covers the complete 0x00-0xFF byte domain.
All 32 byte positions 0x80-0x9F are explicit; the five undefined values remain 0x81, 0x8D, 0x8F, 0x90, and 0x9D.
Active WASM-002 references to W002-GLOSS-037/.2 as mapping authority: 0.
PRODUCT glossary entries are now explicitly informative/non-authoritative.
Mechanical audit: Day060_WASM002_H15_BM12_Mechanical_Audit.txt — PASS.
Status remains PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK.

BM-13 / H-16 evidence

H-16 master SHA-256: B86EA18324626A2F5F1439C397695BB8E707C7322EAA93C563A609072C356242.
Requirement population unchanged: 803 total / 402 SCOPE=WASM-002.
Pre-H-16 stale search attributes under the canonical comparison: 215; post-H-16: 0.
Pre-H-16 case-insensitive superseded-ID whole-master occurrences: 4; post-H-16: 0.
Claude's six named requirements now index DS-CNV-001 and no longer index the superseded spelling.
Sweep artifact: WASM002_BM13_Search_Index_and_Case_Insensitive_Sweep_Day060_H16.html.
Mechanical audit: Day060_WASM002_H16_BM13_Mechanical_Audit.txt — PASS.
Status remains PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK.

BM-14 / H-17 evidence

H-17 master SHA-256: 070EE2970AD27F0541ED711EB598CCBB41AEF1656243F0CD0C5AF21F07BF6249.
Requirement population unchanged: 803 total / 402 SCOPE=WASM-002.
W002-CONV-004.2 now freezes SOURCE_ENCODING: WINDOWS-1252-COMPATIBLE.
W002-CONV-004.3 now freezes MATERIALIZED_ENCODING: UTF-8.
The prior alternate-wording allowance is removed.
W002-STOR-019.10 already separates MAP structural validity from RID/COL health as of H-07.
Mechanical audit: Day060_WASM002_H17_BM14_Mechanical_Audit.txt — PASS.
Status remains PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK.

BM-15 / H-18 evidence

H-18 master SHA-256: 7EC5EACFDB728A42E08F5DC129E67FC5C667FEC65A790833DDF4C97042BFF853.
Requirement population unchanged: 803 total / 402 SCOPE=WASM-002.
DOCTYPE declarations reduced from three to one.
Stale duplicate Day 059 current front matter/status checkpoint removed; Day 060 hero is the sole current front surface.
Omitted-ID table expanded from 19 to 26 unique rows.
All seven BM re-scoped requirements are present with V1-BACKLOG / DEFERRED metadata.
Mechanical audit: Day060_WASM002_H18_BM15_Mechanical_Audit.txt — PASS.
Status remains PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK.

BM-16 / H-19 evidence

H-19 master SHA-256: 30F126B30FC7AAD9E5F93DDF9D3E9CCE2482D3AC10ED986DDABA41539F0D5ED0.
Requirement population unchanged: 803 total / 402 SCOPE=WASM-002.
P2-07 erratum supplied: Red5Sorcery_Data_Sculptor_WASM002_Pass1_Reconciliation_P2-07_Integrity_Erratum_Day059.html.
Dual-hash sidecar supplied: Red5Sorcery_Data_Sculptor_WASM002_Pass1_Reconciliation_P2-07_Integrity_Erratum_Day059.sha256.txt.
Preserved Pass 1 reconciliation SHA-256 verified: 9A73DB717BE09D3ED92B3F0F775EEB09A214000049341FE435B7EC6DFA9255B7.
Corrected successor disposition supplied: WASM002_Carried_Item_Disposition_Day060_H19_Corrected.html.
Malformed H-04 conversion reference expanded to W002-CONV-003 and W002-CONV-003.2; original H-04 evidence remains preserved.
Mechanical audit: Day060_WASM002_H19_BM16_Mechanical_Audit.txt — PASS.
All 16 findings now have integrated responses; status remains PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK.

H-20 coordinated replacement-corpus evidence

H-20 master SHA-256: D4146498C79976B9D5B1B6AD54DAB3579805FDF96FDA535C27F1FA941097B13E.
Replacement corpus ZIP SHA-256: FCDA30503A112B1F327272E8525DAFE644F3E2DA14D54EC08132EE4E5991CB21.
Receipt population: 7 SUCCESS + 27 REFUSED = 34 total.
BM-06 truthful timelines and reachable INV fixture: PASS.
BM-07 repair-WKO inclusion and change-set counts: PASS.
BM-08 RID_ACTION boundary fixtures: PASS.
BM-10 zero-byte/BOM-only Receipt pair: PASS.
BM-11 real undefined-byte CONVERT source/offset: PASS.
Corpus audit: Day060_WASM002_H20_Replacement_Corpus_Audit.txt — PASS.
All 16 findings remain PENDING CLAUDE RECHECK.

Working order

Run final whole-master and 402-requirement scoped-cut mechanical audit.
Build the focused Claude re-check packet with only the H-20 replacement corpus as active fixture evidence.
Ask Claude to re-check BM-01 through BM-16 and issue the freeze-readiness gate.